South African judge weighs an independent expert to work out power overcharges after the regulator's tariff errors
Businesses in five municipalities want unlawful 2025/26 tariffs set aside and credits with interest. One report says Nelson Mandela Bay firms paid 76 per cent more than the power cost to supply.

In 30 seconds
- NERSA, South Africa's energy regulator, has admitted in the Pretoria High Court that it unlawfully approved 2025/26 electricity tariffs in five municipalities.
- Judge RG Tolmay raised appointing an independent expert, under court supervision, to work out overcharges and credits, the Daily Dispatch reports.
- Businesses including Coega Steels want the tariffs set aside and credits with interest, or temporary tariffs while NERSA recalculates.
- Nelson Mandela Bay businesses paid 76 per cent more than the cost of supplying them, Moneyweb reported, according to the Daily Dispatch.
A South African court is now looking at how to pay back businesses that were charged unlawful electricity tariffs.
Last week, the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (NERSA) admitted in the Pretoria High Court that it unlawfully approved 2025/26 municipal electricity tariffs, as we reported. The Daily Dispatch reported on Monday that the tariffs contained significant calculation errors and listed five municipalities: Nelson Mandela Bay, Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Emfuleni and Madibeng.
What the businesses want
The applicants, who include Coega Steels, want the approvals set aside, the Daily Dispatch reports. They are asking for credits for what they overpaid, with interest. As an alternative, they want temporary tariffs while NERSA works the numbers out again.
The paper cites Moneyweb as reporting that businesses in Nelson Mandela Bay paid 76 per cent more for electricity than it cost the municipality to supply it. We have not read the Moneyweb report ourselves.
What the judge asked
Judge RG Tolmay questioned how consumers can be protected from unlawful tariff decisions that keep happening, according to the paper. She raised the idea of an independent expert who would calculate overcharges and credits under court supervision. No ruling date has been reported.
The cost to cities
The case is not simple for municipalities either. Nelson Mandela Bay lost R1.7 billion last financial year to vandalism, electricity theft and billing failures, and expects R1.9 billion this year, the Daily Dispatch reports. Denise van Huyssteen, who heads a local business chamber, told the paper electricity is now the largest cost for many manufacturers, ahead of wages and transport.
What it means for you
Nigeria's tariffs are set by NERC and, in some states, by state regulators. The South African case is a reminder that a tariff order is only as good as the sums behind it, and that customers can challenge them. In Nigeria, regulators publish their orders and hold consultations before big changes. Reading those, and objecting when the numbers look wrong, is how customers protect themselves.
Words to know
- NERSA
- The National Energy Regulator of South Africa, which approves what municipalities charge for electricity.
- Retrospective credit
- Money taken off future bills to make up for overcharging in the past.
Sources
- Daily Dispatch: Nersa blunder puts Eastern Cape businesses in line for tariff relief (16 Nov 2026)
- The Citizen: Electricity tariffs in three metros unlawful, Nersa admits (11 Nov 2026)
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it and say so.