16 November 2026Energy news for Nigeria and Africa, made simpleOil blocksExclusivesEventsEnergy in BriefNewsletterAbout
NairaEnergiesEnergy news, made simple
MarketsUpdated 16 November, 8:22 am

Home / Africa

South Africa's energy regulator admits in court that it approved unlawful power tariffs for three big cities

NERSA told the High Court in Pretoria that the 2025/26 tariffs for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni and Nelson Mandela Bay were unlawful, and called its own approvals "indefensible".

Apollo Converter Station - 001
Photo: NJR ZA, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

In 30 seconds

  • NERSA conceded that electricity tariffs it approved for 2025/26 in Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni and Nelson Mandela Bay were unlawful, The Citizen and EWN reported.
  • Emfuleni and Madibeng municipalities were also named in the case.
  • NERSA missed a 30 June deadline to set new tariffs and asked to phase in corrections over future years. The hearing continues.

South Africa's energy regulator has admitted in court that it approved unlawful electricity tariffs for three of the country's biggest cities.

The National Energy Regulator of South Africa (NERSA) told the High Court in Pretoria that the 2025/26 tariffs it approved for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni and Nelson Mandela Bay were unlawful, The Citizen and EWN reported on Wednesday. Emfuleni and Madibeng were also named. NERSA called its approvals "indefensible", both outlets reported.

How it got here

The challenge was brought by several businesses, The Citizen reported. Among those in the latest applications are Autocast SA, Mpact and Coega Steels.

NERSA had been due to redetermine the tariffs by 30 June but missed the deadline and had not finished by November, The Citizen reported.

NERSA asked the court to let it phase in corrections over future years and to apply them to all users.

"This cannot go on indefinitely," Judge RG Tolmay said, The Citizen reported. She asked the parties for proposals and raised the options of an independent expert or court supervision.

Old problems

The case follows an earlier one. Msunduzi municipality still owes about R200 million in credits to nearly 700 businesses, The Citizen reported. Madibeng last had a lawful tariff around 2013.

The court heard the matter on Monday and the hearing continues. No ruling date has been set.

Why Nigeria should watch

Nigeria has its own fights over tariffs. NERC sets Band A rates, and states such as Enugu and Lagos now have regulators of their own. The South African case shows what can happen when a regulator approves tariffs without checking the numbers behind them: years of court cases, refunds owed and businesses paying more than they should.

What it means for you

A tariff is only fair if the regulator checks the costs behind it. Nigerian customers can ask for the same. NERC and state regulators publish tariff orders, and customers can object during consultations. When a regulator gets the sums wrong, it is consumers and businesses who pay.

Words to know

NERSA
The National Energy Regulator of South Africa, which approves what municipalities charge for electricity.
Tariff
The price per unit of electricity that a customer pays.
Redetermine
To work out and set a tariff again after the first decision is found faulty.

Sources

  1. The Citizen: Electricity tariffs in three metros unlawful, Nersa admits (11 Nov 2026)
  2. EWN: Another Nersa blunder: regulator admits electricity tariffs too high in three metros (11 Nov 2026)

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it and say so.

One email. The week in African energy, simply.

Every Monday: what moved fuel, power and gas prices, what the regulators decided, and what it means for your bill or your business. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.